Column: How two schools won Open Division titles without playing the transfer game
At a time when college sports is in turmoil with no NIL rules, unlimited transfers and players coming and going, there was a historic achievement in Southern California high school sports this past weekend.
Harvard-Westlake and King/Drew won Southern Section and City Section Open Division boys’ basketball championships, respectively, with ZERO transfers on their rosters. Do you realize how astounding that is in this age of transfer mania?
The Open Division was created in 2012-13 so that the most ambitious schools playing the transfer game could be put together and duke it out while letting others play by a different set of rules and philosophies away from them. It was unofficially known as the Transfer Division or the Shoe Division.
At a time when state transfer numbers are nearing a record 17,000 for high school sports in the CIF, winning at the highest level in basketball with zero transfers might provide a different path forward. Call it the old-fashioned way, building from within, developing players from freshmen and not being so quick to chase the AAU way of embracing players and their sometimes delusional parents seeking instant gratification over committing to long-term development.
Yet nothing is really going to change the way things are headed in “amateur†sports. The rise of money in media contracts, the rise in ticket prices, the pressure to win and pay coaches lucrative salaries, the willingness of boosters to ignore rules by offering housing and scholarship money, the influence of private coaches seeking to make money and have a say, it’s clearly a big mess.
What transpired this weekend is that old-fashioned hard work, loyalty to those willing to buy in, competence and trust can win out. Will this once-in-a-lifetime 21st century moment happen again at the highest level? Probably not. We all know that many lack patience, and what happens in pro and college sports eventually seeps down to the high school level.
The protectors of education-based high school sports have their moment to smile. It’s only a moment, though. Football season is six months away and the top schools are already reeling in transfers to replace graduates or take over for players judged not good enough to deliver a championship. Let’s hope some schools stick to the good fight, finding individuals interested in developing students on and off the field instead of just how many trophies they can win by luring another team’s player.
The state regional basketball pairings were released Sunday as the two-week push begins to reach Sacramento to play at the state championships March 8-9 at Golden 1 Center. There could be lots of rematches coming in the Southern California regionals for boys and girls.
Harvard-Westlake and Eastvale Roosevelt drew first-round byes Wednesday in the Open Division boys’ bracket and won’t open play until Saturday’s semifinals. Harvard-Westlake will host the winner between Carlsbad and St. Pius X-St. Matthias. Roosevelt will host the winner of Sierra Canyon and Santa Maria St. Joseph. The regional final is March 5.
The most interesting matchups will be in a stacked 15-team Division I bracket that begins on Tuesday. No. 1-seeded St. John Bosco drew a bye after dropping from the Southern Section Open Division, along with Mater Dei, Corona Centennial and JSerra. Sherman Oaks Notre Dame won the Division 1 championship but was given only a No. 7 seed. Let’s just say someone still isn’t impressed with the 29-3 Knights who own a win over Harvard-Westlake.
In the girls’ Open Division, No. 1 Etiwanda and No. 2 Sierra Canyon drew first-round byes. Etiwanda will face the winner of Mater Dei-Mission Hills while Sierra Canyon will face the winner of Sage Hill-Ontario Christian on Saturday.
More to Read
Get our high school sports newsletter
Prep Rally is devoted to the SoCal high school sports experience, bringing you scores, stories and a behind-the-scenes look at what makes prep sports so popular.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.