Editorial: Firefighters, police should support vaccine mandates if they truly care about communities
Los Angeles Fire Capt. Cristian Granucci recorded a video of himself criticizing the city’s new COVID-19 vaccination requirement. It was posted on YouTube.
It does not bode well for Los Angeles or the end of the pandemic that so many city firefighters and police officers have refused to get vaccinated against COVID-19 and are opposing the city’s vaccine mandate for employees.
The Times recently reported that a group of city firefighters have launched a protest effort, Firefighters for Freedom, “to stop the mandated vaccinations for all city employees as well as the citizens of this great country.†Some 350 firefighters are working with an attorney to block the mandate. And “hundreds†of sworn and civilian Los Angeles Police Department staff have joined Roll Call 4 Freedom, a subgroup of the firefighters’ effort.
These are men and women who have vowed to “protect and serve†and to “preserve life.†They are the city’s emergency responders and front-line medical providers, responding to car accidents, heart attacks, strokes and other events that put them in close, often physical contact with vulnerable Angelenos every day. More than 80% of fire department calls are for emergency medical services.
Yet, now in a pandemic that has killed more than 25,000 people in L.A. County and with the Delta variant causing a resurgence in cases, a disturbingly high number of L.A.’s first responders have decided, duty be damned, it’s more important to fight against public health and for their right to spread COVID-19.
Los Angeles has reopened, but many first responders remain unvaccinated. Just over 50% of the city’s firefighters and police officers have gotten one shot.
It gets worse. Some sworn personnel aren’t just rejecting vaccinations, they’re apparently refusing to wear masks indoors too. One firefighter declared on a radio talk show, “I will not wear a mask. I’m not going to test. And I will not get a shot.â€
Sadly, the backlash isn’t surprising. There’s a been a strong current of vaccine skepticism in the policing and public safety sector, fed by conservative commentators and conspiracy theorists, even though they were among those first in line for vaccinations. Indeed, many sworn personnel immediately signed up for the vaccine, recognizing the need to protect themselves and others. But for months, L.A. leaders have tried to educate, coax and incentivize the holdouts to get the shots. Just over half of the city’s police officers and firefighters have been fully vaccinated.
Last month, Mayor Eric Garcetti signed an ordinance that requires city employees to be vaccinated by early October. Employees with medical conditions or “sincerely held religious beliefs†can request an exemption — and apparently hundreds of workers have indicated they will do so. But those with exemptions must submit to regular testing.
What happens if a city employee refuses to get vaccinated is unclear. The details are still being worked out between city leaders and unions, but other cities have indicated that unvaccinated employees could face unpaid suspension and termination. That is the right call.
A Los Angeles fire captain, Cristian Granucci, recorded a video of himself criticizing the city’s COVID-19 vaccination requirement
The mantra of vaccine mandate opponents is personal freedom — “My body, my choice.†But let’s be clear: People should have a right to decide what goes into their bodies, including lifesaving medication and vaccines, but not the right to endanger the health of other people.
All those Firefighters for Freedom can refuse the COVID-19 vaccine and gamble with their health and lives as an expression of their personal freedom. They just can’t stay on the job and put the public and their coworkers at risk while they are doing so. We’re still in a public health emergency. If a firefighter or police officer is unwilling to take basic precautions to protect others, then he or she should find another career.
A cure for the common opinion
Get thought-provoking perspectives with our weekly newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
