Overrated/Underrated 2018
TV and music writer Chris Barton weighs in on whatâs up and whatâs down in the week in pop culture.
Read more from me on Twitter: @chrisbarton.
- 1
UNDERRATED TV escapism: The ever-shifting news cycle of 2018 often made tuning out the news or your Twitter feed feel like a dereliction of democratic duty.
- 2
UNDERRATED âLeave No Traceâ (2018): Written and directed by the filmmaker behind the grim âWinterâs Bone,â this film set in the Pacific Northwest leaves a deep impression on the strength of its performances and vivid sense of place.
- 3
DâArcy Carden on âThe Good Placeâ: When critics praise this NBC show, whatâs often mentioned is its big heart, gentle charm and an egalitarian ensemble made up of funny people who genuinely like one another.
- 4
UNDERRATED â1983â: A grim, vaguely paranoid bit of alt-history along the lines of âThe Man in the High Castleâ that imagines a world where the Iron Curtain never fell and, curiously, Al Gore was elected president.
- 5
UNDERRATED âThe Bisexualâ on Hulu: Created by and starring Desiree Akhavan (of the Sundance favorite âThe Miseducation of Cameron Postâ), this U.K. series is notable for examining a form of sexuality not commonly seen on mainstream TV but more importantly for being exceptionally funny and heartfelt while doing it.
- 6
UNDERRATED âBonus Familyâ on Netflix: Sure, maybe a subtitled Swedish TV show isnât the easiest sell if youâre entertaining out-of-town guests over a long Thanksgiving weekend.
- 7
UNDERRATED Adam Sandlerâs â100% Freshâ on Netflix: From a critical perspective, Sandler always doesnât have the best track record at the movies or on Netflix (though âThe Meyerowitz Storiesâ remains well worth your time).
- 8
UNDERRATED FilmStruck: Another casualty of corporate mergers thatâs also seen the death of oddball comedy outlet Super Deluxe, this service teamed with the Criterion Collection to provide a valuable resource for film fans who wanted more than whatever archived leftovers lay among Netflixâs content dumps.
- 9
UNDERRATED âSalt Fat Acid Heatâ on Netflix: Hosted by Samin Nosrat (who wrote the 2017 cookbook of the same name), this four-part series is a refreshing shift in perspective from the usual travel-oriented food program.
- 10
UNDERRATED âVery British Problemsâ: Consider this chatty, lightly self-loathing Netflix series should you ever notice the sensation of feeling like âthe ugly Americanâ based on recent developments in the news.
- 11
UNDERRATED âAmerican Fiascoâ: Bearing a title that inspires thoughts of international intrigue, this podcast led by Roger Bennett of NBCâs soccer-centric âMen in Blazersâ examines a fascinating national disaster: The U.S.
- 12
UNDERRATED Gabriel Byrne: The Dublin-born character actor has been enjoying a welcome resurgence of late, lending his occasionally grave presence to a âSuccessionâ-esque patriarch in Netflixâs twisty new series âManiacâ and a beleaguered husband in recent Halloween essential âHereditary.â
- 13
UNDERRATED Nicole Holofcener: A longtime master of richly detailed characters and the often small yet poignant moments that can reveal or upend them, this filmmaker has brought a reliably humane touch to such critically lauded movies as âLovely & Amazingâ and âPlease Giveâ as well as episodes she directed of TVâs âParks and Recreation,â âEnlightenedâ and âOne Mississippi.â
- 14
UNDERRATED âLodge 49â on AMC: Created by short story writer Jim Gavin, this oddball series heading into its final few episodes is your ideal companion for the never-ending Southern California summer.
- 15
Whatâs up and whatâs down in pop culture this week. St.
- 16
UNDERRATED The return of âBig Mouthâ: Arriving with a second season on Oct. 5, this animated series has flown under the radar amid Netflixâs usual avalanche of content, but its comic credentials are solid with voices from Nick Kroll, John Mulaney, Jessi Klein and Jordan Peele telling twisted but also reliably smart and funny stories of the horrors of puberty.
- 17
UNDERRATED Iliza Shlesingerâs âElder Millennialâ: Shlesinger is one of the busiest comedians working today, with multiple specials under her belt since winning NBCâs âLast Comic Standingâ in 2006, and her latest stand-up show is worth finding amid the usual deluge of comedy specials arriving on Netflix.
- 18
UNDERRATED âRandom Acts of Flynessâ on HBO: Created by artist and filmmaker Terence Nance (best known for the revered 2012 feature âAn Oversimplification of Her Beautyâ), this newcomer is billed as a sketch comedy series, but its methods and material stretch well beyond that formatâs usual reach.
- 19
UNDERRATED The Rob Dixon Trioâs âCoast to Crossroadsâ: An Indianapolis-based saxophonist, Dixon assembled a lethal lineup for his latest album.
- 20
- 21
UNDERRATED âRobin Williams: Come Inside My Mindâ: Given Williamsâ impact on pop culture, the documentary treatments were sure to come after his untimely death in 2014.
- 22
UNDERRATED Simon StĂĽlenhag: Get to know the name of this Swedish painter, whose surreal and often haunting images of a future, semi-rural dystopia populated by strange, possibly alien invaders and collapsing technology were just picked up to become an Amazon series called âTales From the Loop.â
- 23
UNDERRATED âThe Endlessâ (2018): Directed by Justin Benson and Aaron Moorhead, this time-twisting indie film requires setting aside our conditioning toward effects-heavy spectacle for an intimate, strangely affecting story.
- 24
UNDERRATED The ensemble pleasures of âGlowâ: When the odds-on Emmy contenders include the grueling second season of âThe Handmaidâs Taleâ and the viewer-testing puzzlebox that was the last season of âWestworld,â itâs a genuine treat to spend a half hour or so with each new episode of this Netflix series.
- 25
UNDERRATED Hannah Gadsbyâs âNanetteâ: With Netflixâs habit of releasing stand-up comedy shows with the care of an alpine avalanche, youâd be forgiven for losing track of this new special, which may be the most affecting hour of television youâll watch this year.
- 26
UNDERRATED âHumor Meâ (2018): Sometimes â more and more, lately â life requires a straightforward comedy with strong performances and a tidy sense that everything is going to turn out OK, and thatâs where this movie comes in.
- 27
UNDERRATED The World Cup: Fox Sports may be experiencing a bit of buyerâs remorse after winning the rights to this monthlong event but lost some luster after the U.S. team failed to qualify for the first time since the Reagan administration.
- 28
Whatâs up and whatâs down in pop culture this week.
- 29
UNDERRATED âJohn Mulaney: Kid Gorgeous at Radio Cityâ: Heâs achieved acclaim as a writer on âSaturday Night Liveâ and âDocumentary Now!â
- 30
UNDERRATED John Goodman: With the first season of the new âRoseanneâ behind us, maybe we now have the distance to look past the many reads on the politics of the show and the Twitter antics of its star to appreciate the showâs steady center in Dan Conner.
- 31
UNDERRATED The return of âHarvey Birdmanâ: This gloriously strange relic reminds us of a time before Adult Swim was established as a fertile source for twisted comedy and rare Flying Lotus tracks.
- 32
UNDERRATED âBig Dreams, Small Spacesâ on Netflix: With summer not-so-slowly creeping around the corner in Los Angeles, itâs an ideal time to grow familiar with this import, which is set in the damp green spaces of Britain.
- 33
UNDERRATED Todd Marcusâ âOn These Streetsâ: Ask most pop culture fans for their impressions of West Baltimore, and the response will usually be rooted to HBOâs grim document of the war on drugs, âThe Wire.â
- 34
UNDERRATED The supporting cast of âDeadpool 2â: Violent and vulgar, the first âDeadpoolâ felt a little like watching a stand-up comic who keeps stopping his set to remind you how edgy his material is.
- 35
UNDERRATED Michael Palin in âThe Death of Stalinâ: Given Armando Iannucciâs track record for acidic political comedy with âVeepâ and âIn the Loop,â there were no steadier hands to find a pitch-black mix of absurdity and horror in this shockingly funny look at the maneuverings after the fall of the Soviet Unionâs strongman.
- 36
UNDERRATED âKilling Eveâ on BBC America: Marking an unconventional next move for Phoebe Waller-Bridge, who gave us the darkly funny âFleabag,â this new series finds her adapting the novellas of Luke Jennings for the story of Eve, a previously desk-bound MI-5 agent (Sandra Oh) in pursuit of a cold-blooded international assassin, Villanelle (Jodie Comer).
- 37
UNDERRATED Meltdown Comics: Given how the box office typically looks, few might have guessed you can go out of business serving geek culture, and yet thatâs what has happened to this shop on Sunset Boulevard.
- 38
Overrated/Underrated: âTabula Rasaâ is your next Netflix obsession, and in praise of Yo La Tengo
UNDERRATED âTabula Rasaâ on Netflix: A tangled combination of haunted house horror and a missing person mystery, this series was a breakout hit in Belgium, and it should be a first stop for those in need of a spookily atmospheric binge.
- 39
UNDERRATED Bill Camp in âThe Looming Towerâ: As entertainment, there are more relaxing shows than this Hulu drama about the organizational rivalries and breakdowns that failed to avert the 9/11 attacks.
- 40
UNDERRATED âUgly Deliciousâ on Netflix: Just when it seemed television had exhausted various ways to build a show around the genius chef, the genre finds new ground in the hands of Momofuku czar David Chang.
- 41
UNDERRATED âThe Breadwinnerâ: Destined to be overshadowed in the animated feature category thatâs traditionally dominated by Disney/Pixar, this moving film now streaming on Netflix deserves greater notice regardless of Sundayâs outcome.
- 42
UNDERRATED Chris Rockâs âTamborineâ on Netflix: Maybe itâs a result of the streaming serviceâs habit of flooding the field with stand-up comedy, but more attention should be given to the first special in 10 years by an undisputed master of the form.
- 43
UNDERRATED The Winter Olympics: Arriving with less fanfare than their summer counterparts with their tidily marketed narratives of American dominance, the Winter Olympics deserve equal notice for the opposite reason.
- 44
Overrated/Underrated: âSomebody Feed Phil,â and the how long is long enough for a farewell tour?
UNDERRATED âSomebody Feed Philâ on Netflix: In a food and FOMO-obsessed TV landscape thatâs given a show to almost every chef with a passport, thereâs something refreshing about this series led by comedy writer and âEverybody Loves Raymondâ creator Phil Rosenthal.
- 45
UNDERRATED âA Futile and Stupid Gestureâ on Netflix: A sort of companion to the 2015 documentary âDrunk, Stoned, Brilliant, Deadâ (also streaming on Netflix), this biopic of National Lampoon co-creator Doug Kenney directed by âWet Hot American Summerâsâ David Wain builds a bridge between generations of the oddball vanguard of comedy.
- 46
UNDERRATED âIngrid Goes Westâ (2017): Starring Aubrey Plaza and Elizabeth Olsen, this edgy comedy about a stalker energized and enabled by her Instagram feed isnât quite the biting satire of social media and its many hashtag-adorned â#influencersâ we need, but it comes close.
- 47
UNDERRATED Joe Frank: If you moved to Los Angeles at a certain time and of a certain temperament, Joe Frank was the voice in your head offering an immersive, vaguely unsettling welcome.
- 48
- 49
UNDERRATED Michael Stuhlbarg in âCall Me by Your Nameâ: How is a presumptive Oscar contender underrated?