Review: Preachy ‘Guillotines’ carves out a dull tale
- Share via
Andrew Lau’s “The Guillotines” is a historical action epic set during the Qing dynasty that amounts to a bait-and-switch for wuxia fans stoked for steel-meets-flesh mayhem.
Reel ‘em in with a mighty weapon: an intricately bladed discus hurled from a curling sword, which then locks on a victim’s neck and cleanly decapitates. Up the stakes with the secret assassin clique of the title, led by stoic commander Leng (Ethan Juan) and tasked by the emperor to take down a dangerous rebel prophet named Wolf (Huang Xiaoming). Soon loyalties curdle, the Guillotines find themselves on the run, and a second half of vengeful, course-correcting adventure seems at hand.
Instead, the big reveal: a preachy, sociopolitical drama about oppression, outmoded leadership, and the simple beauty of a working class allowed to live in collective harmony. Gee, thanks.
REVIEW: More movie reviews from the Times
There’s a nod to the entwined-destiny of antagonists that Lau made much more gripping in his great crime flick “Infernal Affairs,” but here it’s much more leaden.
And that nasty, nifty, head-slicing tool? Another point-making prop when firearms and cannons become the emperor’s weapons of choice and the Guillotines are rendered obsolete: War is now so impersonal!
An action fan could be forgiven for the medicinal taste that this slick but dissipating exercise leaves behind.
--
‘The Guillotines.’
MPAA Rating: R for strong violent content.
Running time: 1 hour, 53 minutes.
Playing: At Laemmle Music Hall 3, Beverly Hills, and Playhouse 7, Pasadena.
More to Read
Only good movies
Get the Indie Focus newsletter, Mark Olsen's weekly guide to the world of cinema.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.