What Ryan Murphy’s and Harry and Meghan’s deals say about the state of Hollywood
A few years ago, it seemed every week there was a new eight- to nine-figure deal between a high-profile writer-producer and a Hollywood studio or streaming service.
These lucrative pacts made people like Shonda Rhimes, Ryan Murphy and J.J. Abrams essentially in-house producers for entertainment companies that were in an arms race to lock down top-tier talent for the streaming wars.
Even people with limited to no experience in entertainment secured rich deals based largely on name recognition, such as former First Family Barack and Michelle Obama and the Duke and Duchess of Sussex. But lately such deals have fallen out of fashion among some executives, as media and entertainment companies rethink how they spend their resources.
The thinking behind these mega-deals was for the popular showrunners to bring in bigger audiences and help fill the platforms’ libraries with new hit series. But as subscriber growth on streaming services has slowed, companies are analyzing whether it’s worth it to renew the deals.
“I do think these deals are going to be fewer and farther apart because there’s a lot of belt-tightening right now,†said Susanne Daniels, YouTube’s former global head of original content, who now teaches at UCLA. Daniels estimates the number of new signings of so-called overall deals will drop significantly next year.
The Ringer founder Bill Simmons called Prince Harry and Meghan Markle ‘grifters’ after their Archewell Audio and Spotify announced that they cut ties.
Earlier this month, a podcasting deal between Prince Harry and Meghan Markle’s Archewell Audio and Swedish streaming giant Spotify came to an end, after the royals’ company produced just 12 episodes of a single show in 2½ years. Spotify executive and the Ringer founder Bill Simmons, speaking on his own podcast, called them “f— grifters.†The Montecito-based couple still has a Netflix deal and has produced series including docuseries “Harry & Meghan,†“Live to Lead†and the upcoming “Heart of Invictus,†which will come out this year.
Murphy, the much more productive and experienced producer behind “American Horror Story†and “Glee,†is said to be in talks for a new deal with Disney, five years after signing a deal worth up to $300 million at Netflix. Netflix and a representative for Murphy declined to comment. Disney did not respond to a request for comment.
The Disney deal talks are advanced but not finalized and aren’t expected to conclude until the Writers Guild of America strike ends, according to people familiar with the matter who were not authorized to comment.
Murphy’s output at Netflix had mixed results. Early efforts, such as “The Politician,†“Hollywood†and “The Prom,†didn’t do as well as the company would have liked, industry observers said. However, two of Murphy’s later shows, “Dahmer — Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story†and “The Watcher,†were successful.
How platforms like Netflix and Prime Video measure success can mean the difference between life and death for a show. But those metrics remain opaque.
“Dahmer†has been watched for more than 1 billion hours and is Netflix’s third-most-popular English-language show, according to company data. The first season of “The Watcher†is ranked 10th, with more than 447 million hours watched. Murphy still has several projects in the Netflix pipeline, including two more installments of the “Monster†franchise.
“They had to spend a lot of money early on because they were trying to drive subscriber growth, and I think they’re in a position now where they’re watching a little bit more closely the money that they’re spending,†said Ryan Webb, a Los Angeles-based entertainment attorney at Greenberg Glusker.
The streamer has said it plans to keep its content spending at around $17 billion on average annually through 2024.
While Murphy and the royals represent wildly different situations, the shuffles come as streaming services are looking closely at their finances amid Wall Street pressure to pare down costs. Many tech and entertainment companies have laid off staff and canceled programs.
Even big-name hit makers such as “Alias†creator Abrams’ production company Bad Robot have found themselves under the microscope. Warner Bros. Discovery-owned HBO last year decided not to move forward with the Bad Robot sci-fi series “Demimonde†due to a disagreement about the budget. Bad Robot in 2019 signed a $250-million overall deal with what was then called WarnerMedia.
Why many members of the Writers Guild of America have targeted streaming giant Netflix in their fight for higher streaming residuals.
Hollywood studios also are grappling with a writers’ strike, which has shut down productions as the Writers Guild of America pushes to increase the amount of money scribes make from streaming.
Insiders expect studios to use the strike to trigger force majeure clauses that allow them to exit deals. However, companies may have reasons to be careful when using that cost-cutting tool, said Elsa Ramo, managing partner at Ramo Law PC, an entertainment firm.
“There may be political reasons or messaging reasons or relationship reasons that could temper a very cutthroat business decision that you’re contractually allowed to do,†Ramo said. “I think those conversations are happening right now.â€
Led by Netflix’s pacts with Shonda Rhimes and Ryan Murphy, streamers have lured TV titans with eye-popping deals. The results have been mixed at best.
The pullback is especially acute in the podcasting industry, where some companies have struggled to make money despite the rapid growth in the number of shows produced.
Spotify Chief Executive Daniel Ek said during an April earnings call that the company wants to avoid “overpaying†for exclusive talent in podcast deals. The company has restructured its podcasting division and made efforts to reduce its costs, including by recently cutting 200 jobs and consolidating Gimlet and Parcast, two production companies it acquired. Popular hosts include the controversial comic Joe Rogan, who has a licensing deal with Spotify worth an estimated $200 million.
“We’re going to be very diligent in how we invest in future content deals,†Ek said on the call. “The ones that aren’t performing, obviously we won’t renew, and the ones that are performing, we will obviously look at those on a case-by-case basis on the relative value.â€
Netflix has thrown more than 800 balls inspired by its popular ‘Bridgerton’ show. For fans, it’s their chance to reimagine themselves as characters on the show.
While the writers’ strike and the economic environment have caused a lull in overall deals, companies have still signed some major pacts recently and doubled down on existing relationships.
Netflix renewed its landmark agreement with Rhimes in 2021 and announced an expansion of training programs with her Shondaland production company earlier this year.
Shondaland has created some of Netflix’s biggest hits, including “Bridgerton†and its spinoff show, “Queen Charlotte: A Bridgerton Story,†as well as the limited series “Inventing Anna.â€
Last year, Walt Disney Co.’s 20th Television and ABC Signature extended their overall deal with former NBC executive Warren Littlefield’s production company. In 2021, “Insecure†showrunner Prentice Penny signed an overall deal with Disney’s Onyx Collective. Earlier this year, “Fleabag†creator Phoebe Waller-Bridge renewed her deal with Amazon Studios. In January, Warner Bros. reupped its pact with prolific TV producer Greg Berlanti.
“There will always be a demand and a premium paid for talent that can deliver, especially if someone has an established track record,†said entertainment lawyer Briana Hill, a partner at Pryor Cashman.
Inside the business of entertainment
The Wide Shot brings you news, analysis and insights on everything from streaming wars to production — and what it all means for the future.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
