Opinion: 9/11: No prayers for you
This article was originally on a blog post platform and may be missing photos, graphics or links. See About archive blog posts.
New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg is being lacerated for not including any clergy in the principal ceremony marking the 10th anniversary of 9/11. Nor will there be a prayer.
If a minister can deliver an invocation at a presidential inauguration, it’s hard to see a constitutional argument against a non-denominational, clergy-led prayer at a city’s memorial event.
One of the arguments for clergy-led prayer is that it’s innocuous -- a form of what legal scholars call ‘ceremonial deism.’
But here’s the catch: If various religions earnestly believe in propositions that are unique to them -- say, the saving power of Jesus’ death for Christians -- a non-denominational prayer is a kind of betrayal.
Perhaps the argument against that sort of observance isn’t legal but religious.
RELATED:
The United States of ‘Jesusland’?
9/11: Using poetry to cope with tragedy
9/11 and Al Qaeda: The price of victory
9/11: Lower Manhattan, 10 years after [Photo essay]
--Michael McGough
