As Orlando mourns, Charleston remembers shooting that claimed nine lives a year ago

Nine ribbons in honor of the victims killed in last year's shooting at Emanuel AME Church blow in the breeze in front of the church in Charleston, S.C.

By Associated Press

June 17, 2016 4:34 PM PT

Reporting from CHARLESTON, S.C. — South Carolina’s governor somberly held up programs from the funerals of the victims of last year’s Charleston church shootings, saying Friday during a memorial service that the faith of those victims showed how to heal in the aftermath of still another mass shooting.

“As for me, I will forever know that there are angels on Earth,” said Gov. Nikki Haley during a three-hour service that was somber yet punctuated by joyous singing.

Coming just days after the massacre in Orlando, Fla., Friday was the anniversary of the shooting deaths of nine black worshipers during a Bible study at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church. A white man, Dylann Roof, faces charges in both state and federal courts, and prosecutors in each are seeking the death penalty.

Haley, who attended the funerals of all the victims, said she got to know the families of those who were killed and the three survivors in the days and weeks following the shootings.

“There hasn’t been a day since June 17, 2015, that I haven’t thought about the 12,” she said.

South Carolina Gov. Nikki R. Haley holds a photo of Clementa C. Pinckney as she speaks during a memorial service on the anniversary of last year's deadly shooting at a Charleston church.

She recalled each victim, sometimes with gentle humor, as she showed the funeral programs she says she keeps as reminders.

The Rev. DePayne Middleton-Doctor “had the voice of an angel,” she said.

Haley recalled state Sen. Clementa C. Pinckney, the Emanuel AME pastor who was slain, as “a gentle giant” and a man “who never talked about what he was against. He always spoke about what he was for.”

Haley said that in the wake of the shootings — after which many family members of the victims said they forgave the gunman — the people of South Carolina “didn’t have protests, they had vigils. They didn’t have riots, they had hugs.”

The College of Charleston’s TD Arena, where the service was held, seats about 5,000 people and was about half full. The stage was lined with the pictures of the nine people killed. Above each were the words “Still Speaking from Eternity.”

It’s the same venue where President Obama last year led the congregation in “Amazing Grace” during the funeral for Pinckney.

A presidential aide read a message to the congregation from Obama and the first lady in which they said “as a nation we are deeply moved by your boundless love and your unshakable resilience.”

ALSO

In Orlando, Obama reprises role as comforter-in-chief

Victims of the Orlando nightclub massacre: Who they were

In a week of mourning in Orlando, members of the LGBT community vow to stay resilient