‘So You Can Think You Can Dance’: Nigel Lythgoe on show’s 10 seasons

Fox’s “So You Think You Can Dance� has ridden the wave of dance show popularity and will complete its 10th season with Tuesday night’s finale.

Along with creating successful dancers and choreographers, the show (also known as “SYTYCD�) can lay claim to introducing some big musical artists. Both Lady Gaga and Katy Perry had their first breakout national performances on the show.

Other artists who’ve been on the show early in their careers include Adele, OneRepublic and Goldfrapp. The show is also receiving more recognition this year with seven Emmy nominations, including one for host Cat Deeley, and a 42-city tour kicking off Oct. 1.

Executive producer Nigel Lythgoe, who along with Simon Fuller created “SYTYCD,� is also one of the judges. We caught up with him to talk about what’s changed in the show’s first 10 seasons and where the dance world is now.

INTERACTIVE: Fall 2013 TV preview

ST: When you began the show, how did you think it would go?

NL: I will say that I wasn’t anticipating that the show would be successful. Simon Fuller suggested that we do a show similar to his “American Idol� show. With my background as a dancer, we should look into doing it for dancing, and I didn’t think it would work. Pure and simple because I didn’t think the public wanted anything to do with dancing. “Dancing With the Stars� wasn’t on the air yet and there was nothing in America, or anywhere else for that matter, that led me to believe that it would be successful. However, we tried “So You Think You Can Dance� as a pilot, and it was horrible. It just didn’t work at all. We changed it around, and after that first series I thought we were getting on the right track. There were some really good dancers that came out of it. And the eventual winner, Nick Lazzarini, was fantastic. There was certainly talent here ripe to be picked. But the big thing to me was something that we’d never really taken into account. The choreographers, and how their stories turned out and how we’ve watched them be creative and paint pictures for themselves. That, for me, was the thing that I was really most interested in at the end of the first season.

ST: “SYTYCD� has had great staying power with it’s ‘dance and be judged’ format. Is it the judges, the dancers, the story lines or a combination that is the secret to its success?

NL: The show’s secret to success is the American dream -- that’s no secret. That is, the realization that you can shine and that there is an opportunity to shine, and this gives hope to these kids that may have come from nothing, may have not even have had the opportunity in the socio-demographic areas that they were in to get out of it. Dance has given them the opportunity, and “So You Think You Can Dance� has given them the platform. So, it’s a lot deeper than ‘dance and be judged.’ A lot deeper. Like an onion. there are many layers, one that we’ve touched on with the choreographers. Look at how they’ve developed. This country now knows choreographers’ names. Mia Michaels. Wade Robson. Travis Wall. And we’ve reinvested in them. Travis was a contestant, and has come back. The genuine stories behind them. Mia Michaels’ park bench routine and its impact on the Emmys.

I don’t necessarily think the judges play anywhere near the part that they do on “American Idol.� We’re not really celebrities in that sense. We’re just trying to be good, honest people. We don’t want to cut anybody’s legs off without rebuilding them with pointed toes. We want to be constructive with our comments and be helpful, while at the same time try not to pat them on the head and give them a lump of sugar.

PHOTOS: Cable versus broadcast ratings

ST: In the 10 seasons that “SYTYCD� has been on, have you seen major changes in the dance world?

NL: What I would say is that dance has become far more acceptable in this country. I’m seeing huge changes of elitism disappearing, and the ballet world is realizing that there is another world of dance out there that it may have been ignoring. I think that there’s a lot of development and movement in that elite world, which is really good to see. I now see street kids that have had no formal training inspiring kids who have had formal training. The street kids also now know that there’s an awful lot of hard work that they have to do, that they have to train their bodies and their minds when using classical forms as a technique and they can do even more with their own styles. I watched a kid this year, Fik Shun, get better and better at his own style because he began strengthening up in other areas. This realization has been occurring over the past six or seven years, and I’m also watching families accept their children as dancers. They realize that they’re not just dancers, they are athletes.

I think there’s a lot more happening with inner-city kids too. Communities are using dance as we lose money from the arts for our schools and everything. Communities are getting together and realizing that we can put all of this information in a kid’s head, but if the kid isn’t creative, they’re not going to disseminate it very well. You need to be creative in this world, not just intelligent, and creativity and intelligence don’t always go hand in hand, as far as I can see. Dance is such a great form to be creative and be good for your health that I think people are looking on dance in a totally different way. When I first started “So You Think You Can Dance,� a black girl came up to me and said, ‘You know, only white people will ever win this competition,’ which knocked me back. I said ‘Well, why do you say that?’ And she said, ‘Because they’re the only ones who can afford proper training.’ Thank goodness she was wrong. It was something that needed to be addressed, and certainly it has been, and I think “So You Think You Can Dance� has made an impact in that area and shown the great beauty of the diversity of dance, and hopefully tried to give it the respect it deserves.

ST: In this 10th season, what has happened that surprised or affected you?

NL: I think the stand out surprise was that one of my favorites got cut early on. I’ll name names ... Aaron was not in our top 20, and made it to the four finalists, and Jasmine crept in. When we were discussing it, she wasn’t in our top 10, and Cat Deeley really fought for her. Our minds were easily changed at that stage. It just shows the strength of everybody, and I think it’s the first time in the finals where I thought, ‘Wow, I wish we could split the prize money four ways.’ I don’t think our two boys are exceptionally talented in technique, aside from Aaron with his tap and Fik Shun with his creativity, but they both bring something unique in terms of personality. Both our girls are fabulous in both technique and performance. America has a really tough job on their hands this week.

ST: What are a few of your favorite routines from over the years?

NL: I think Mia Michael’s bench routine was certainly one of the first that made people think, ‘Oh wow! This is about a serious subject here.’ A sort of unrequited love that Mia Michaels had for a gay man that loved her, but couldn’t love her in a physical way.

Wade Robson’s Ramalama. Tyce Diorio’s breast cancer routine. Mia Michaels’ addiction piece. It’s perfect when the music is right, when the dancing is right, and when the dancers really understand what they’re doing.
-- Jevon Phillips

ALSO:

Emmys 2013: Cat Deeley on ‘So You Think You Can Dance’

Paula Abdul to guest judge on ‘So You Think You Can Dance’

VIDEO: ‘So You Think You Can Dance’ judges talk 9th season