'The X Factor' recap: Simon goes missing, L.A. gets older

By Amy Reiter

Sept. 20, 2012 12 AM PT

As if to prove we’d miss him if he were gone, Simon Cowell was absent from the first half of “The X Factor’s” two-hour audition episode on Wednesday night, and the show really wasn’t the same without him.

It was as if all the tension had been let out of the room and all that was left was some people singing and some other people issuing a few pleasantries before sending them off with either a yes or no. Which is to say it was as listless and lackluster as Britney Spears’ uncombed locks. (Please, for the love of Christina, can’t someone please stage an intervention and get her a better hair and makeup person? Or at least move her away from that glowy Demi Lovato?)

In fact it was Spears who broke the news that Cowell would be sitting out the Kansas City, Mo., auditions because he was sick and that “some guy Louie” would be filling in. “Louie” turned out to be British “X Factor” judge Louis Walsh, who seemed a kindly enough sort, but was, it must be said, no Simon Cowell. (Who is?)

“Are you missing Simon?” Walsh asked his new besty L.A. Reid at one point during the show.

“Of course I’m missing him,” Reid replied, “but not that much.”

Reid did his best to keep the auditions moving along in Cowell’s absence, but of course, he wasn’t Simon either. And the veteran producer may have been a little distracted by the fact that it was his birthday, a milestone duly noted by Lovato and Spears, who brought him a modest cake (Cowell would have conjured a showier celebratory confection for sure) and breathily serenaded him in a moment that was vaguely reminiscent of Marilyn Monroe’s “Happy Birthday, Mr. President.”

When the auditions moved on to San Francisco and Austin, Texas, Cowell returned, triumphantly, strolling in confidently in his trademark white T. And not a moment too soon. Simon? We can’t abide you, but please don’t ever leave us again.

Auditions included:

Rizzloe Jones: This Kansas City 18-year-old called himself an “ADD animal of freestyle rap” and unleashed some on-the-spot lyrics for the judges. Personally, I wasn’t impressed, except maybe by the fact that he worked the word “marshmallow” in there at Lovato’s request. The judges, though, picked up what Jones was laying down. Reid said he liked Jones’ “flow,” and Spears compared him to “Vanilla Ice ice baby,” favorably, it seems. Four yeses.

CeCe Frey: The producers set us up not to like this leopard-face-painted, fiercely competitive 20-year-old mail clerk, showing her trying to gaslight other contestants awaiting their auditions. “I’m not in this thing to make friends,” she said, echoing the sentiment of many a reality-TV show villain. “I’m in it to win it.” Surprisingly, she got one step closer. The judges complimented her on her “ambition” and “attitude” – Lovato even said she had a “girl crush” on the short-shorts-wearing singer – and she made it through.

Vino Alan: If Frey was soft on the outside and steely within, this tough-looking, tattoo-headed dude may be precisely the opposite. Alan, who plays shows for the military, said he was working to bring stability to his 15-year-old son’s life, and then proceeded to sing a moving, emotional “Trouble.” The judges found it “interesting” and “unique” and even “inspired,” but warned him “Don’t let us down, man.” Why would they think he’d let them down?

DeAngelo Wallace: Speaking of trouble, this mouthy contestant got into a heap of it. First, he ticked off the judges so extremely with his nasty talk and off-key singing that they simply stood up and walked out. They’re “too scared to face me,” Wallace said afterward, calling them devil-worshipers to boot. Then he took off with a $3,000 microphone and had to be tracked down by police. As he was cuffed and shuttled into the cop car he sang that he’d be out of police custody in just a few hours. He turned out to be right. Perhaps DeAngelo has done that sort of thing before?

Tate Stevens: This cowboy-hat-wearing 37-year-old road worker and dedicated dad was packed with personality, saying he’d throw himself a big ol’ party and invite everyone to come if he won the show’s $5-million prize and saying “Thanks, mom” to an appreciative heckler. He said he’d been “waiting for a chance like this” his whole life, and he took full advantage of the opportunity, wowing the crowd and the judges. Reid said he was “mad” at Stevens for waiting so long to go for his dream and declared him to be a “true country star.” Lovato predicted, “I am going to be listening to your record one day, over and over again.” Yes, the man in the hat’s going to Boot Camp.

Citizen: This group of boy-band wannabes — all about the clothes and the hair gel — tried to prove they were about the talent as well. Their cheesy take on “Don’t Let Go” by In Vogue impressed Reid, Spears and Lovato. Simon, not so much. “I didn’t get it,” Cowell said, calling it “10 years out of date” with out-of-shape vocals to boot. “It’s like you’re in a time machine for me,” he added. Sadly, Cowell was outvoted.

Diamond White: This sparkling 13-year-old, who lives in a “shoebox apartment” in Los Angeles with her mom, said she was hoping to get her own bed and her own room. She tackled “It’s a Man’s Man’s Man’s World” and sang with a voice and depth well beyond her years. “Your mother got it right,” Reid said. “You are a diamond.” Cowell commended her for blowing “the roof off the place” and called her “incredible.” On to Boot Camp with her.

Ally Brooke: This 18-year-old with big dreams – she not only wants to sing and act but also wants her own perfume line and basically to be “as big as Beyoncé” — pleased the judges with her take on Jaci Velazquez’s “On My Knees.” Spears noted that her voice had a “theatrical dynamic” and gave her an “easy-breezy yes,” which Cowell matched with an “easy, easy breezy yes.” Brooke breezed through to Boot Camp.

And after quick clips of silky-voiced Brandon Hassan, bold Normani Hamilton and sibling act Sisters C making it through, we were treated to three final acts:

Jeremiah and Josh: This duo’s original song prompted Spears to wish they’d wake her up in the morning. (She meant on her clock radio, she explained.)

Panda: A highlight of the show, this sassy singer — who carries a torch for Cowell, calling him her “baby daddy” and springing herself from the hospital, where she was being treated for pneumonia just to see him — brought the house down with her suggestively soulful “Bring It on Home.” Everyone was impressed but perhaps especially Cowell, who said, “Panda, you sound like a legend. I absolutely love you.” He “always wanted a panda,” he said, but – uh-oh – Panda had pushed herself too far and ended up being carted back to the hospital in an ambulance. “I don’t want Simon to see me like this. He’s gonna think I can’t do it,” she begged through her oxygen mask. “Don’t let Simon see this.” Poor Panda!

Jessica Espinoza: Another breakout talent, 22-year-old Espinoza, from the south side of San Antonio, Texas, said she hoped to smooth out her family’s rocky road with success on the show. She was off to a good start. The judges loved her take on Pink’s “Nobody Knows.” “Wow, you are really special,” Reid told her. “Really, really special.” Cowell gave her one of his “I didn’t like it” … pause … “I loved it” reviews and she emerged at the top of the pack.

What did you think of Wednesday night’s auditions? Any favorites?

ALSO:

‘The X Factor’ recap: Britney Spears is creeped out, and so are we

‘The X Factor’ recap: Season 2 brings us Britney and Demi

Upfronts 2012: Britney Spears and Demi Lovato officially join ‘X Factor’